Parents have the most significant impact on their children’s lives. Parents might not always believe this; the Parents Education Empowered study suggested parents ranked themselves last among their children’s influences, behind peers, teachers, and the media. However, when asked the same question, the youth ranked their parents first, ahead of families, peers, teachers, and activities/clubs.
But who has more influence on children between father and mother? When it comes to child custody cases, whether after a divorce or not, it has long been assumed that mothers have an advantage over fathers, moms are the highest, according to court documents in the United States.
The message is simple for these fathers who are losing end of custody battles and desperately wish joint or sole custody of their children. You must be a woman to be a good mom. There are some studies, on the other hand, that tend to disagree with that message.
But, aside from custody, who has the most influence over their children? It differs significantly from situation to situation, but the general seems to be that mothers have a more significant influence on daughters and fathers have a greater influence on sons. Various researchers, on the other hand, have different opinions on the topic.
Today, mothers and fathers are often involved in raising their children, and it is no longer considered the responsibility of mothers solely. So, who do you think is the preferred parent? Which one is more crucial: your mother or your father?
For this article, we will be analyzing who influences children more through the influences of mothers and fathers individually and how family members interact to stay active . We will support them with research and facts, which will finally help us answer the age-old question: Who Influences Children More, The Father Or The Mother?
Influence Of Mothers On Their Children
Mothers are excellent at a multitude of activities. They are far more caring and have a more natural way of handling children, especially babies.
Mothers are also known for being fixers, always ready with a needle and thread to sew a teddy bear’s arms back together no matter what time of day it happens. They’re the ones who always seem to find socks, can always get stains out and are the people to make a call to when something goes wrong.
Mothers are also found to be the source of comfort for children of all ages due to these reasons. Three-year-old are more likely to call out their fathers when they want to play outside. Most fathers take pride in this fact. But they need their Mommy when they get hurt, get scared or wake up in the middle of the night.
It is a fairly common occurrence, and it is most likely due to gender norms. According to experts, fathers are more invested in avoiding damage in the first place than in soothing children in the aftermath.
And as there is children’s development, they become less comfortable displaying vulnerability in front of, and opening up to, their fathers. Meanwhile, their bonds with their mothers strengthen.
Do Children Express Better In Front Of Mothers?
The nurturing role of females, in general, means that children can be more vulnerable in their presence. It is proven to be true for children of all ages, from infants to teenagers. They can express themselves better in front of their mother than their fathers.
When it comes to infants, researchers discovered that mothers awoke three times a night on average to care for crying babies, while fathers awoke closer to twice a night. This experiment of co-sleeping with their children derived a few conclusions.
And, while mothers typically soothed babies with food, calming lullabies, and rocking, fathers who awoke in to respond to a crying child spent only about 40% of their awake time tending to the infant. Fathers spent most of their time checking up on the mother and then on the baby.
Similarly, According to the findings of a 2017 study on how mothers and fathers cope with their toddlers’ pain, children of mothers who participated in more physical reassurance showed higher pain intensity levels.
It is not to say that mothers are poor comforters; on the contrary, they are incredibly successful. When children seek support from their mothers, they are more likely to exaggerate their pain responses or express how they feel. Toddlers go to their mothers to be comforted and to weep freely. Kids, on the other hand, act tough when their fathers are present.
What Studies Suggest ?
As for studies on teenagers, mothers were scored vastly higher than fathers on acceptance, commitment, cognitive development, and strict control. It implied that adolescents perceived mothers as more active, understanding, and likely to adopt strict control.
Another study suggested that parenthood might be turning adults into their mothers. According to a recent study that received sponsorship by the Welcome Trust and presented in the European Journal of Public Health, our mothers have a much more significant influence on how we rear our children than our fathers do.
The study showed that parents who described their mothers as affectionate exhibited more affection and positive parenting actions towards their children, while parents who described their mothers as controlling exhibited more negative parenting behaviours. Researchers couldn’t identify any signs that fathers influenced their child’s potential parenting style in any way.
There have been numerous research on parental influence over the last few decades, and all of them attribute plenty of positive outcomes to Mother rather than Father. According to a 2012 report, a mother’s love can positively affect a child’s brain. And the 2013 study that found mothers had the most significant influence on a daughter’s body image.
Influence of Father on Their Children
Fathers are viewed as the breadwinners with broad shoulders. They aren’t given much respect for how they deal with the stresses of raising a child or for their domestic skills. The prejudice, beyond out of date, seems to stick with them.
The influence that fathers put on their children is also often diminished by the media. The media appears to profit from tales of deadbeat dads, bringing to light the stories of reckless and irresponsible fathers who either don’t care or cannot care for their children. Constantly being fed this knowledge deprives fathers of the credit they deserve.
Research conducted in the Journal of Family Psychology examines the relational role of fathers in daughters’ lives. Positive father-daughter bonds have many advantages, according to the results.
Respondents who have a harmonious relationship with their fathers were better at dealing with tension in daily circumstances. They are less likely to be victims of severe depression or anxiety.
Furthermore, warmer relationships “related to emotional support and reliability” affect future relationships. According to the researchers, these subjects were also more receptive to voicing themselves and sharing their thoughts and needs.
When they get older, this can lead to more fulfilling friendships and healthier, more satisfying romantic relationships.
What Studies Suggest ?
Randall Day, a professor in the School of Family Life and co-author of a Brigham Young University study published in 2012, agreed that fathers directly influence how children experience perseverance and optimism and how they apply it in their lives.
It’s important to note that mothers can do this as well. But it turns out that it affects how their adolescents perceive the world when fathers use authoritarian parenting.
As per the 2006 study “Fathers And Their Effect On Children’s Development Well-Being,” Father has a significant impact on our self-esteem, and it begins early. Children are able to deal with someone who bullies them in real or personally in applications like WhatsApp. Children who have an involved father are more likely to be emotionally stable, confident to explore their environments and have stronger social connections as they grow older.
According to a Michigan State University report, children who spend more time with their fathers have improved social skills, mental wellbeing, and even a better sense of humor. A separate study linked father involvement to happiness. It claimed that children with active fathers were much less likely to be unhappy.
However, more value is always placed on mothers, and fathers’ influence, despite the evidence, is permanently diminished. It might be the result of traditional parenting techniques and gender norms. But the norms are changing, and the value of both father and mother is being realized these days.
Mothers as The Dominant Influence
According to a recent study performed by Gallup News among 1000 adults in the US. American people are even more likely to believe that their mothers were the most influential people in their lives. From early childhoods kids are attached to mothers for simple things like eating, sleeping and over-all development.
According to the latest data, more than the half of American adults (53 per cent) believe their mother had the most impact on them. But the gap among the influence of mothers and fathers seems to be declining.
The percentage of people who say their fathers had a more significant impact on their lives when growing up is higher than when Gallup first asked this question in 1951. According to the most recent data, 28 per cent of adult children believe their father is the more dominant parent, up from 22 per cent in 1951.
Males more than females to state that their fathers had the most impact on their lives. The differences widen when both genders and age receive consideration. Although 40% of males aged 18 to 49 believe their fathers were more dominant than their mothers. This percentage drops to 23% for males aged 50 and older.
Who Influences Children More?
Mothers, according to society. However, there will always be some fathers who disagree. Parenting is not a race, nor should adults be petty and always keeping score so that they can turn up in court one day and claim to be the best.
Children need both of their parents, regardless of whether they are male or female or whether they share DNA or not. Both parents either of the opposite or same-sex have an influence on child development.
Friends, cousins, grandparents, relatives, teachers, coaches, same-sex couples or any other people are involved in raising a kid. It is to remember that among the father and the mother the one who genuinely love and care about their child’s needs, interests are by far the best of all.